Value for money has been misread. It’s time to fix it.

Value for money has been misinterpreted for decades. Somewhere along the way, it became shorthand for “lowest price” or “lowest risk”.

That is not value.
That is cost minimisation.

‍And on major projects, cost minimisation can be the most expensive decision of all.

‍How we got here

‍Price is easy to measure. It sits in a single cell on an evaluation spreadsheet.

Risk is easier to defend. Choosing the biggest, most established bidder rarely gets anyone questioned.

‍So procurement drifted toward what could be counted and defended, not what creates the most value.

The result is a narrow view of value. It rewards the lowest number on the day and ignores what happens after the contract ends.

What value for money really includes

‍True value for money looks past delivery. It includes: ‍

  • Capability uplift - suppliers who finish the project more capable than when they started.

  • Workforce development - skills, training and jobs that stay in the region.

  • Regional resilience - local economies that can absorb shocks and take on the next project.

  • Supply chain diversification - less reliance on a few providers, and less exposure when one of them fails.

  • Long-term competitiveness - Australian businesses able to compete for future work, here and overseas.

‍These are industry participation outcomes.
They are not nice-to-haves.
They are value. ‍ ‍

Contract value is a snapshot. Economic value is a legacy.

‍ A contract price tells you what a project costs during delivery. It tells you nothing about what the project leaves behind.

Two bids can have the same price and very different legacies. One leaves behind a stronger supplier base, a trained workforce and a region ready for what comes next. The other leaves behind a finished asset and nothing else.

If both are scored the same, the evaluation is missing something.

Why this matters for industry participation policy

‍Industry participation policy exists to give local businesses full, fair and reasonable opportunity to take part in major projects. But policy only goes as far as procurement lets it.

When procurement decisions ignore economic value, they undermine industry participation policy. Commitments are made in plans, then lost at the evaluation table.

When procurement decisions include economic value, they strengthen it. Participation becomes part of how projects are judged, not a box ticked on the side.

This is not theory. It is economics.

A supplier that grows capability today reduces delivery risk tomorrow.

A region that strengthens its workforce today becomes competitive tomorrow.

A diversified supply chain today becomes resilient tomorrow.

Each of these lowers future cost and future risk. Leaving them out of value for money does not make procurement more disciplined. It makes it less accurate.

The rules already point this way

This is not a new idea. It is already in the framework.

Under the Commonwealth Procurement Rules, value for money is the core rule, and price is not the only factor. For procurements above $1 million (or $7.5 million for construction services), officials must also consider the economic benefit of the procurement to the Australian economy.

The intent is clear.

The gap is in how it is applied.

Too often, economic benefit is weighted lightly, assessed loosely or treated as a tiebreaker. It needs to be a real part of the decision.

What needs to change

Value for money must evolve. In practice, that means:

  • Defining economic value upfront - setting out what capability, workforce and regional outcomes the project should deliver before the tender goes to market.

  • Weighting it properly - giving economic value real weight in evaluation, not a token percentage.

  • Asking for evidence, not intent - looking for credible delivery plans, not broad statements.

  • Measuring after delivery - tracking what was actually achieved, so the next procurement decision is better informed.

‍Value for money must include the value created after the contract is delivered, not just the cost during delivery.

Hughes et al POV

‍For nearly 20 years, we’ve worked with major projects, governments and regions on industry participation.

‍We see the same pattern again and again. The decisions that look cheapest on paper are not always the ones that deliver the most value.

The projects that leave a lasting legacy are the ones that treat economic value as part of the decision, not something added afterwards.

Our position is simple.

If value for money doesn’t include economic value, it isn’t value for money.

Previous
Previous

Why Procurement Systems Struggle to Deliver Industry Participation Outcomes